Disputes about online games
|Disputed games for Naruto resolved during the month of November|
|Game date:||November 2, 2012 (lasted 42 minutes)||Disputed by:||dakotabeboys|
|Player A:||macniako with the deck Guns Style (BLOCK)|
|Player B:||dakotabeboys with the deck True Allies FTW!!|
|Reviewed by:||streckster98 on November 3, 2012|
|Final outcome:||Won by dakotabeboys||re-play >>|
As for the disagreement, both players see here: http://www.bandai.com/naruto/showthread.php?t=95177
dakotabeboys could not use Gale Style: Laser Circus to injure Tsukado and then just give 1 damage to it to discard it, but he could use both the effects. A moderator at Bandai states in the link above that if "X" is paid with 2 or more the effects of Laser Circus apply in the order they are listed, meaning they both are and can be applied.
As for the game, dakotabeboys was in favor of winning. As you can see here http://www.tradecardsonline.com/im/forum/viewtopic/p=109277///#109277 the herald for Naruto at TradeCardsOnline states that a player having more Battle Rewards than his/her opponent when either player has reached his/her 5th turn is a reason for him/her to be declared the winner. Both players were past their 5th turns, and dakotabeboys had more Battle Rewards than macniako.
Even if this wasn't the case, macniako's use of inappropriate language makes dakotabeboys the winner of this game.
|Game date:||November 4, 2012 (lasted 55 minutes)||Disputed by:||mr_smailey|
|Player A:||starkb with the deck brutal style|
|Player B:||mr_smailey with the deck Weapon Disaster (RaTE)|
|Reviewed by:||streckster98 on November 4, 2012|
|Final outcome:||Won by starkb||re-play >>|
As for the disagreement about Wind Style: Vacuum Blast's cost, mr_smailey's source was incorrect about not being able to pay 0 for X. See here: http://www.bandai.com/naruto/showthread.php?p=1199051#post1199051
As for the disagreement about Twin Sword Hiramekarei: Hammer, starkb was also right. You pay the Jutsu's 2 generic Chakra to add it to the chain, then you can pay an additional 2 generic Chakra for the user to gain +4/+4. The stand-by making part applies after you decide whether you want to pay an additional 2 or not. Either way, Hammer goes to the Chakra after its entire effect resolves, so you cannot pay the additional 2 with Hammer after it goes to the Chakra, because that would mean its effect is still applying and shouldn't have been moved to the Chakra yet. See here:
Therefore, mr_smailey was cheating or at least was attempting to.